Indiana Code Title 28. Financial Institutions § 28-7-5-35

Sec. 35.  If more than one (1) person shall claim the right to redeem a pledge, the pawnbroker shall incur no liability for refusing to deliver the pledge until the respective rights of the claimants shall have been adjudicated.  If no action be brought against the pawnbroker by either party within the period for which the pawnbroker is required under section 30 of this chapter to hold the pledge, or within one (1) month after notice of an adverse claim, the pawnbroker may proceed to sell the pledge subject to adjudication of the parties' rights.